Italian And Its Dialects: The Clever Linguistic Choices In ‘My Brilliant Friend’

Italian dialects show just how difficult the task of translation can be.
Author's Avatar
Italian And Its Dialects: The Clever Linguistic Choices In ‘My Brilliant Friend’

Header photo: Eduardo Castaldo/HBO

In the Neapolitan novels, a four-book series by Elena Ferrante that has seen enormous success in Italy and around the world, a fundamental role is given to language; in particular, the books highlight the dichotomy between the Neapolitan dialect and standard Italian, which punctuates the series’ events like a leitmotif

Yet despite being mentioned regularly, Ferrante never uses dialect in the series’ Italian-language narration (except for some slang expressions, like strunz, càntaro, tàmmaro and uommen’e mmerd). The author often reminds us that the characters are speaking in dialect, but their dialogues are, in fact, written in standard Italian.

For example, in a memorable scene in the first book My Brilliant Friend, when Lila threatens Marcello Solara by pointing a knife at his throat, the narrator writes,

She said calmly, in dialect, “Touch her again and I’ll show you what happens.”

The presence of the dialect is important, almost omnipresent, but it’s never shown explicitly. During an interview with Katrina Dodson in Guernica, Ferrante’s American translator Ann Goldstein shared an interesting reflection on the reasons for this choice: “The obvious reason Ferrante doesn’t use dialect is because many Italians wouldn’t understand it. But a second reason may be that, as an Italian professor at CUNY was saying, Neapolitan dialect is very much a spoken language, and if she were writing it, there would be no point, in a way. It would lose the character that it has as a spoken language.”

So it’s not by chance that the characters in the TV series based on My Brilliant Friend speak in the Neapolitan dialect, perhaps exactly because it’s a natural medium to bring across the essence of the spoken dialect.

Inclusion/Exclusion

The dialect–standard Italian duo closely concerns the two main characters of the Neapolitan novels, Elena and Lila. They both use language to convey their identity in the world.

For Elena, who is unhappy in the poor and violent circumstances of her childhood, adopting standard Italian is a way to emancipate herself from her neighborhood. But at the same time, it becomes a barrier that separates her from her family and her friends. There’s a wonderful and poignant scene where Elena, back in Naples after getting her diploma in Pisa, forces herself to talk to her mother and discovers a new barrier to communication: 

“Language itself, in fact, had become a mark of alienation. I expressed myself in a way that was too complex for her, although I made an effort to speak in dialect, and when I realized that and simplified the sentences, the simplification made them unnatural and therefore confusing. Besides, the effort I had made to get rid of my Neapolitan accent hadn’t convinced the Pisans but was convincing to her, my father, my siblings, the whole neighborhood.” 

In Pisa, Elena feels excluded because of her Neapolitan accent, but in Naples they call her “the Pisan” and mock her for speaking standard Italian. 

The question of mastering a language as a means for inclusion on one hand and exclusion on the other not only concerns the general social sphere, but also interpersonal relationships. 

At the beginning of the book, speaking standard Italian brings Elena and Lila together. As children, they enthusiastically speak “in the language of comics and books,” which inevitably excludes others in their neighborhood.  However, the situation changes shortly afterward, when standard Italian becomes more often the language of concealment — as opposed to dialect, which is the language of authenticity — becoming an obstacle destined to divide the two protagonists. Narrating one of her last conversations with Lila, Elena says,

“It occurred to me that it was now a linguistic question. She resorted to Italian as if to a barrier; I tried to push her toward dialect, our language of candor. But while her Italian was translated from dialect, my dialect was increasingly translated from Italian, and we both spoke a false language.”

A Difficult Translation

With a text like Neapolitan novels, so closely linked to Naples and Italian history, transposing into another language is far from a piece of cake, and the problems go past just dealing with Italian dialects. 

Beyond the descriptions of the city and the historical, political and cultural references, one of the concepts that gave translators the most difficulty is smarginatura: “On December 31st of 1958 Lila had her first episode of dissolving margins. The term isn’t mine, she always used it. She said that on those occasions the outlines of people and things suddenly dissolved, disappeared.”

Ann Goldstein explains that smarginatura is a technical term from the field of typography which means “cutting off the margins of a page.” She started with the literal translation “trimming the edges,” “losing the edges,” then “dissolving the margins” or “dissolving the boundaries,” ending up with “dissolving margins,” an expression that – according to her – “better expresses the emotional substance and the original meaning of the word at the same time.”

Want to learn Italian?
Try Babbel Today!

Recommended Articles

An American And An Italian Discuss Elena Ferrante’s ‘My Brilliant Friend’

An American And An Italian Discuss Elena Ferrante’s ‘My Brilliant Friend’

We talked to one of our Italian correspondents to dig into the language and culture of Elena Ferrante’s ‘My Brilliant Friend’!
The 8 Best Films For Learning Italian

The 8 Best Films For Learning Italian

Lucky for you, Italian cinema is one of the best ways to supplement your language learning. Here are 8 of the best movies to learn Italian.
5 Very Good, Very Specific Tips To Learn Italian

5 Very Good, Very Specific Tips To Learn Italian

Is it difficult to learn Italian? Maybe you just need some hints to help you succeed. Here are our 5 very specific tips for learning Italian, from a linguist and Italian native speaker!
Author Headshot
Silvia Gilardi
Ghostwriter and creative writing teacher, Silvia is a voracious reader. In addition to books, she loves the sea, owls, movies, languages and the color blue. She has a weakness for Russian, which she recently started studying. The thing that excites her most is writing.
Ghostwriter and creative writing teacher, Silvia is a voracious reader. In addition to books, she loves the sea, owls, movies, languages and the color blue. She has a weakness for Russian, which she recently started studying. The thing that excites her most is writing.
Pick a language to speak